P.T. Barnum and Consumer Debt

Mar 18, 2015 | Debt, Foreclosure

Most people remember P.T. Barnum for the line – “there’s a sucker born every minute.” Great – if not cynical -line, but Barnum never said it.

I have been thinking of him in a slightly different context lately, however. Over the past two weeks or so I’ve made a series of posts on my Facebook page concerning consumer debt – all of them pretty sobering. Like the New York Times article about car repossessions and military personel.   

I seems that when cars are illegally repossessed by lenders, there is no recourse through the courts. There is a clause in many – many – financial contracts that require all disputes be settled in binding arbitration. Only.

The fact that the lender can, many times, pick the arbitrator, pick the city (the Times piece states that they inevitably pick the city farthest from the debtor), keep all decisions secret.

There’s more, most of it infuriating.

It all reminded me of a Barnum story that is true. He owned and operated Barnum’s American Museum on the corner of Ann Street and Broadway in New York for years in the mid-1800s. It was open 15 hours a day, averaged 15,000 visitors a day and was immensely profitable.

Tickets cost 25 cents. It had a zoo, theatre, lecture hall, wax museum, freak show, and every manner of popular culture Barnum could cram into it.

It also had large signs, usually placed by one wonder or the other proclaiming THIS WAY TO THE EGRESS!

Unsuspecting ticket holders would rush to see the egress – perhaps thinking pre-historic flightless waterfowl. They’d follow the signs and find themselves in the alley.

They would hike back to the entrance – the museum was a full city block, so it was a hike – and try to go back in . . . at which time they would be instructed to look on the back of their ticket. Where it was clearly spelled out, albeit in very small type, that the ticket was void the minute the patron exited the building.

They could drop another 25 cents – not a small amount of money in 1860 – and go back in or they could slink home. Either way they learned the definition of ‘Egress’.

I’m thinking consumer debt has a lot of P.T. Barnum in it these days, and the financing companies are getting more creative every day.

Latest in Articles

I’ll talk to anyone who is currently behind on their mortgage, thinks they may not be able to afford their mortgage in the coming months, or is already in foreclosure. The earlier we talk, the more options you have.

… Sarah Poriss.

Sarah Poriss, Attorney at Law, LLC is the largest woman-owned foreclosure defense law firm in Connecticut, providing homeowners with quality legal counsel in foreclosure mediation and foreclosure defense.

Working at Consumer Law Group in Rocky Hill, Connecticut for four years, Sarah specialized in representing consumers facing financial crises like debt collection harassment and identity theft. Upon opening her own office, she expanded her focus to defending consumers sued by credit card companies and representing homeowners in foreclosure.

Sarah has elevated her practice by exclusively representing clients with money issues. She played a crucial role in drafting foreclosure mediation rules as a member of Connecticut’s Bench-Bar Foreclosure Committee for seven years.

Additionally, she contributed to the Bench-Bar Small Claims Committee to enhance clarity in small claims proceedings and ensure debt collectors provide substantial evidence to win cases.

Ever wanted to pick a lawyer's brain without the complexities of hourly rates and retainers?

This is why we offer you a simple and affordable solution: A One Hour Session for $300. 

During your one-hour session, we will identify crucial adjustments in your financial strategy that can be implemented immediately!


We will address your immediate concerns and devise a strategy to enhance your financial well-being.


Fill out "What Money Matters To Me". This confidential questionnaire a tool is used, maximizing our time together.


We explore your financial concerns, identify areas for improvement, and craft your customized roadmap.


You leave with actionable steps, resources tailored to you, and the confidence to navigate improved financial health.